What Does The Union Say Against Fi-Core?

By Jeff Hatch

First off, if you opt for Fi-Core, the Union will no longer recognize you as a member. As mentioned earlier, they say plainly on their website that you will be labeled an FPNM, and they will regard you as an anti-union "scab" (a derogatory term for non-Union workers who fill Union jobs during a strike). Well, the term "fee paying non-member" is technically an oxymoron. How can you pay fees, retain your performer number and be represented by the Union in all collective-bargaining activities and yet be a "non-member"? If you were truly a non-member, you wouldn't be paying dues and you wouldn't be represented by the Union. It would be more accurate to call FC actors "second-class" members, as I said before, but it's their union. They could call you a duck if they wanted to, it doesn't make you a duck.

The SAG-AFTRA website also declares that FC members may not identify themselves as SAG-AFTRA on their resumes, websites, business cards etc. Since Core members are no longer members in good standing, the Union has a right to keep them from using their name to promote themselves. However, they say nothing about simply identifying as "Union: Fi-Core" which lets producers know you are OK to work Union or non-Union projects. I would argue that Fi-Core actors ought to be able to use "SAG-AFTRA: Fi-Core" on their resumes. Adding the designation "Fi-Core" let's potential employers know you are not a full member and it should keep them from being able to do anything legally since you are not misrepresenting your status in any way. However, if you want to be safe and avoid controversy, I've seen a label such as "Union Member: Fi-Core Status" used on a resume along with the actor's performer number as evidence of membership. That seems like a good compromise.

SAG-AFTRA also insists that by going Core, you are hurting other actors in the Union. This statement is pretty much completely true. As we established earlier, Fi-Core does indeed hurt the union by weakening its power in the industry. By extension this hurts full SAG actors because it lessens the Union's effectiveness in contract negotiations. The Guild has had to compete with the recent boom of non-Union projects over the past several years, along with the influx of new digital media. In order to keep low-budget productions from going non-Union, they've had to lower the pay scale for certain film, TV and digital contracts and lower- or even eliminate- residuals on many commercial contracts. So, even the Union jobs on many projects these days don't pay much better than a lot of non-Union gigs thanks- in part, to the growing number of FC actors.

The pro-Fi-Core defense on this point is that this is simply the way it is. Just as certain conditions exist in the workplace that sometimes make unions necessary, likewise, certain conditions exist within unions that make options like Fi-Core equally necessary. Also in a very demonstrable way, SAG itself created the conditions that made the Core option necessary, or at least very attractive, to many actors.

For decades actors have been allowed into the Union with very few prerequisites. All that's required to join is three SAG vouchers from doing extra work on a union set and pay the initiation fee. No training, auditions, evaluations or apprenticeships are required. The result has been a steady stream of new actors with no verified training and no clue how to get work in this business. But the Guild is nonetheless happy to take the ever-increasing initiation fee (currently $3,000) and the bi-annual dues from thousands of new actors every year. And with potentially hundreds of Guild actors vying for any one SAG role, the Union ought not be surprised that people would opt to "hurt their fellow actors" by seeking employment outside the fold.

Maybe you won't worry about hurting SAG's feelings, but you might worry about what people in the industry, who might hire you, think.

Next: Is There Really A Stigma Against Fi-Core Actors In The Industry?


This is one of a series of questions and answers regarding Financial Core for SAG-AFTRA members. Jump to a question:

Intro: Everything You Wanted To Know About Fi-Core But Were Afraid To Ask

What is Financial Core?

Why Would A SAG-AFTRA Actor Want To Go Fi-Core?

Why Would An Actor NOT Want To Choose Fi-Core? What Are The Consequences?

What Does The Union Say About Fi-Core And What Are The Arguments For It?

Is There Really A Stigma Against Fi-Core Actors In The Industry?

Will I Lose My Pension And Benefits?

Right To Work And Fi-Core Permanence

What If I'm SAG-AFTRA And Just Take Non-Union Gigs 'Under The Radar?'

How Many Fi-Core Members Are There?

Fi-Core And The SAG-AFTRA Merger

Does SAG-AFTRA Offer More Detailed Information About Financial Core?

How Would I Go About Getting On Fi-Core Status?

Is The Financial Core Option Right For Me?

References And Resources

About Jeff Hatch

Jeff Hatch trained as a theatre actor in college and conservatory programs and appeared in regional and local theatre in Southern California, Utah and Arizona before pursuing Film and Television in LA. He has worked in several TV, Film and Commercial projects over the past 10 years. He has recently booked several roles in independent feature films, shorts, a prime-time network comedy, a daytime soap and multiple re-enactment documentary programs. Read more about Jeff on IMDb.

Standard Guest Post Disclaimer

We are grateful to the author of this article for sharing their experience and point of view, but because this is a guest post it does not necessarily completely represent the views of Karmalicity.

What Is Karmalicity?

Karmalicity is "Karmic Publicity" for actors, directors and other Film Industry Professionals.

We are a supportive community of more than 8,000 members. Members use Karmalicity to connect, to improve their social media numbers, and to share in each others' success!

If you are a Film Industry Professional with an IMDb page, head to the front page and register for free!

What Members Say

"For me, Karmalicity is changing the game! I've been a working actor for almost eight years, and throughout the process, there's always been some way to get an edge in publicity. Remember back when the most important thing was a black and white headshot? Then they became color. Then they went to digital. Then it was a website! Then it was a digital online reel!

Well, now Karmalicity has taken it to a whole new level! Digital publicity! I've seen more new actors and been seen by more industry people through this website than I thought possible. My IMDB rating has improved by leaps and bounds! I'm going to tell all my friends about my success on this site. People say the most productive thing you can do in creating a career is to DO SOMETHING! I'm glad that Karmalicity has given me the chance to do something to directly affect mine. "
Kenzo Lee
Kenzo on IMDb